Republicans Strike Out on Medicare “Doc Fix”

Will Republicans have the fortitude to repeal ObamaCare? Maybe, but when push comes to shove, Republicans have been unwilling to expose the entire political-medical complex to sunshine, which is a prerequisite for repeal. Witness last Friday’s unanimous passage in the U.S. Senate of a standalone, so-called, “doc fix” for Medicare Part B.  This “doc fix” kicks the can down the road until the end of November.

As I recently wrote, Congress can never really fix the “doc fix” because politicians cannot correct a centralized, Soviet-style method of calculating physicians’ fees.  The best that they could do is simply to eliminate it entirely.

So, there is no reason for Senate Republicans to crow about their collaboration with the majority to pull the “doc fix” out of the more comprehensive “extenders” bill, in a last ditch attempt to prevent the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services from ordering physicians’ reimbursements to be cut by over one fifth starting this week.

First, two thirds ($4.2 billion) of the $6.5 billion increase in physician reimbursements will come out of Medicare payments to hospitals, by forcing them to bundle together all inpatient and outpatient claims incurred within three days of admission. The Senate proposes simply to take money allocated from one Soviet-style, price-fixed part of the health sector and transfer it to another. The hospitals will soon be lobbying for their “fix,” as this new policy sinks its teeth into them.

Second, the balance of the money comes from a hike in corporate-tax revenues — the effect of a change in pension-fund accounting that will allow corporations to reduce their contributions and therefore book more taxable income. (This, of course, ignores the fact that corporate pensions are hardly ship-shape, and even the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation’s solvency is questionable, as George P. Shultz and John B. Shoven discuss in a book which I reviewed a while back.)

Senate Republicans are correct that their most recent in a series of never-ending short-term “doc fixes” doesn’t increase the deficit, but that’s only because of a tax hike and a raid on hospitals. It doesn’t reduce the role of government in medicine, and it’s hardly a good warm-up for the main event of repealing ObamaCare.

8 thoughts on “Republicans Strike Out on Medicare “Doc Fix””

  1. A complicating factor is that the doctors are not much better than the politicians. The American Medical Association, for example, is just another special interest group.

  2. The sustainable growth rate formula is little more than a convoluted, top-down approach to enforcing a global budget on individual physicians. It is akin to paying physicians fee-for-service, but reducing the fees so the total doesn’t exceed a pre-determined pool of money. The problem with this approach is that bureaucrats cannot really know what the market price that should be paid or how much care is the appropriate amount that should be provided. Looking at the SGR from an economist’s point of view, there is very little likelihood that any bureaucracy could get it right.

  3. The AMA is more than just one more special interest. It is a special interest that pretended to be representing doctors during ObamaCAre while all the while selling them out.

  4. Since the AMA is making so much money off of the existing system, they are never going to agree to change it.

  5. NPR had an interview with Joseph Califano who oversaw the implementation of medicare in 1965. He said that when medicare started, they originally went to the doctors and agreed to pay them whatever the doctors felt was reasonable (as long as it wasn’t too out of line). Of course each year, the doctors believeing that they were “above average”, would inflate their charges by 5-10%. Pres Johnson and his advisors realized soon after medicare started that the costs were much greater than they anticipated. They went to Congress and pleaded to get a change. But it was too late. By this time, the seniors, doctors and politicians liked it. Decades later, we’re still wrestling with how much to pay. That’s why it’s so important to get it right from the start.

  6. The sad thing here is that the Seniors get left out of the mix. While Congress and the AMA wrestles with short term “fixes” to a broken system the physicians are leaving the Medicare system in droves. Who is going to be left to take care of the aging Baby Boomers? As a student FNP I am willing to carry this burden, but I must have an MD to supervise me. If Advance Practice Nurses had more independence we could serve as a gatekeeper for senior citizens to access the health care system.

Comments are closed.